ConvexBench: Can LLMs Recognize Convex Functions?

Convex analysis is a modern branch of mathematics with many applications. As Large Language Models (LLMs) start to automate research-level math and sciences, it is important for LLMs to demonstrate the ability to understand and reason with convexity. We introduce cb, a scalable and mechanically verifiable benchmark for testing textitwhether LLMs can identify the convexity of a symbolic objective under deep functional composition. Experiments on frontier LLMs reveal a sharp compositional reasoning gap: performance degrades rapidly with increasing depth, dropping from an F1-score of 1.0 at depth 2 to approximately 0.2 at depth 100. Inspection of models' reasoning traces indicates two failure modes: textitparsing failure and textitlazy reasoning. To address these limitations, we propose an agentic divide-and-conquer framework that (i) offloads parsing to an external tool to construct an abstract syntax tree (AST) and (ii) enforces recursive reasoning over each intermediate sub-expression with focused context. This framework reliably mitigates deep-composition failures, achieving substantial performance improvement at large depths (e.g., F1-Score = 1.0 at depth 100).