Non-Transferable Learning: A New Approach for Model Ownership Verification and Applicability Authorization
On the map: LLM safety and security → Watermarking generated content and models
Abstract (arXiv)
As Artificial Intelligence as a Service gains popularity, protecting well-trained models as intellectual property is becoming increasingly important. There are two common types of protection methods: ownership verification and usage authorization. In this paper, we propose Non-Transferable Learning (NTL), a novel approach that captures the exclusive data representation in the learned model and restricts the model generalization ability to certain domains. This approach provides effective solutions to both model verification and authorization. Specifically: 1) For ownership verification, watermarking techniques are commonly used but are often vulnerable to sophisticated watermark removal methods. By comparison, our NTL-based ownership verification provides robust resistance to state-of-the-art watermark removal methods, as shown in extensive experiments with 6 removal approaches over the digits, CIFAR10 & STL10, and VisDA datasets. 2) For usage authorization, prior solutions focus on authorizing specific users to access the model, but authorized users can still apply the model to any data without restriction. Our NTL-based authorization approach instead provides data-centric protection, which we call applicability authorization, by significantly degrading the performance of the model on unauthorized data. Its effectiveness is also shown through experiments on the aforementioned datasets.
Key facts. Cited by 52 papers in the map (data through 14 Oct 2026). Placed in Watermarking generated content and models, one of 12 directions in LLM safety and security. Builds on 43 of its 66 references that are in the map. First posted on arXiv 13 Jun 2021.
Builds on
43 of 66 references.
References · 43
- 2015Deep Residual Learning for Image Recognitioncited by 52,096
- 2014Very Deep Convolutional Networks for Large-Scale Image Recognitioncited by 15,364
- 2015Domain-Adversarial Training of Neural Networkscited by 3,044
- 2016Membership Inference Attacks against Machine Learning Modelscited by 2,281
- 2014Conditional Generative Adversarial Netscited by 2,162
- 2015Learning both Weights and Connections for Efficient Neural Networkscited by 2,031
- 2016Neural Architecture Search with Reinforcement Learningcited by 1,499
- 2015Learning Transferable Features with Deep Adaptation Networkscited by 1,329
- 2016InfoGAN: Interpretable Representation Learning by Information Maximizing Generative Adversarial Netscited by 860
- 2020Do We Really Need to Access the Source Data? Source Hypothesis Transfer for Unsupervised Domain Adaptationcited by 848
- 2017VisDA: The Visual Domain Adaptation Challengecited by 435
- 2017Measuring Catastrophic Forgetting in Neural Networkscited by 360
31 more
- 2018Turning Your Weakness Into a Strength: Watermarking Deep Neural Networks by Backdooringcited by 357
- 2020Learning to Learn Single Domain Generalizationcited by 296
- 2020Learning to Generate Novel Domains for Domain Generalizationcited by 296
- 2017MMD GAN: Towards Deeper Understanding of Moment Matching Networkcited by 254
- 2017Embedding Watermarks into Deep Neural Networkscited by 248
- 2020Universal Source-Free Domain Adaptationcited by 220
- 2017Emergence of Invariance and Disentanglement in Deep Representationscited by 215
- 2017Machine Learning Models that Remember Too Muchcited by 169
- 2020Robust and Generalizable Visual Representation Learning via Random Convolutionscited by 142
- 2020Efficient Domain Generalization via Common-Specific Low-Rank Decompositioncited by 134
- 2020Domain Generalization for Medical Imaging Classification with Linear-Dependency Regularizationcited by 123
- 2019Updates-Leak: Data Set Inference and Reconstruction Attacks in Online Learningcited by 122
- 2020Maximum-Entropy Adversarial Data Augmentation for Improved Generalization and Robustnesscited by 121
- 2017Adversarial Frontier Stitching for Remote Neural Network Watermarkingcited by 118
- 2020Learning to Learn with Variational Information Bottleneck for Domain Generalizationcited by 102
- 2021Progressive Domain Expansion Network for Single Domain Generalizationcited by 97
- 2019[Extended version] Rethinking Deep Neural Network Ownership Verification: Embedding Passports to Defeat Ambiguity Attackscited by 88
- 2018Technical Report: When Does Machine Learning FAIL? Generalized Transferability for Evasion and Poisoning Attackscited by 81
- 2021Unsupervised Multi-source Domain Adaptation Without Access to Source Datacited by 76
- 2016Amortised MAP Inference for Image Super-resolutioncited by 68
- 2019How to Prove Your Model Belongs to You: A Blind-Watermark based Framework to Protect Intellectual Property of DNNcited by 66
- 2019Correlation-aware Adversarial Domain Adaptation and Generalizationcited by 65
- 2020What Can Be Transferred: Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Endoscopic Lesions Segmentationcited by 50
- 2018Effects of Degradations on Deep Neural Network Architecturescited by 48
- 2019REFIT: A Unified Watermark Removal Framework For Deep Learning Systems With Limited Datacited by 44
- 2019Eavesdrop the Composition Proportion of Training Labels in Federated Learningcited by 27
- 2020One for Many: Transfer Learning for Building HVAC Controlcited by 16
- 2017Self-ensembling for visual domain adaptationcited by 12
- 2019Deep Neural Network Hyperparameter Optimization with Orthogonal Array Tuningcited by 11
- 2020Deep-Lock: Secure Authorization for Deep Neural Networkscited by 10
- 2021Weak Adaptation Learning -- Addressing Cross-domain Data Insufficiency with Weak Annotatorcited by 8
Built on by
Citing papers per year: 2022: 4; 2023: 11; 2024: 14; 2025: 16; 2026: 7.
52 papers.
Sort:
By area:
- 2023LoRA Fine-tuning Efficiently Undoes Safety Training in Llama 2-Chat 70Bcited by 195
- 2023The Science of Detecting LLM-Generated Textscited by 128
- 2022Federated Class-Incremental Learningcited by 127
- 2024Representation Noising: A Defence Mechanism Against Harmful Finetuningcited by 96
- 2023Domain Watermark: Effective and Harmless Dataset Copyright Protection is Closed at Handcited by 57
- 2024On Large Language Model Continual Unlearningcited by 52
- 2022Dataset Inference for Self-Supervised Modelscited by 36
- 2023Federated Incremental Semantic Segmentationcited by 36
- 2024Immunization against harmful fine-tuning attackscited by 35
- 2025REFINE: Inversion-Free Backdoor Defense via Model Reprogrammingcited by 22
- 2022PolicyCleanse: Backdoor Detection and Mitigation in Reinforcement Learningcited by 19
- 2025Rethinking Data Protection in the (Generative) Artificial Intelligence Eracited by 18
38 more
- 2023Reinforcement Unlearningcited by 17
- 2024SOPHON: Non-Fine-Tunable Learning to Restrain Task Transferability For Pre-trained Modelscited by 17
- 2023Model Barrier: A Compact Un-Transferable Isolation Domain for Model Intellectual Property Protectioncited by 14
- 2023DEJA VU: Continual Model Generalization For Unseen Domainscited by 13
- 2023A Survey on Class Imbalance in Federated Learningcited by 13
- 2023Towards Robust Model Watermark via Reducing Parametric Vulnerabilitycited by 10
- 2025AdLift: Lifting Adversarial Perturbations to Safeguard 3D Gaussian Splatting Assets Against Instruction-Driven Editingcited by 10
- 2025Jailbreaking the Non-Transferable Barrier via Test-Time Data Disguisingcited by 8
- 2025DuFFin: A Dual-Level Fingerprinting Framework for LLMs IP Protectioncited by 8
- 2024Say No to Freeloader: Protecting Intellectual Property of Your Deep Modelcited by 7
- 2025Toward Robust Non-Transferable Learning: A Survey and Benchmarkcited by 7
- 2025Catch-Only-One: Non-Transferable Examples for Model-Specific Authorizationcited by 7
- 2022Unsupervised Non-transferable Text Classificationcited by 6
- 2024DeepEclipse: How to Break White-Box DNN-Watermarking Schemescited by 5
- 2025When Data-Free Knowledge Distillation Meets Non-Transferable Teacher: Escaping Out-of-Distribution Trap is All You Needcited by 5
- 2026Delving into the Temporal Challenges of Unified Video Protection Against Image-to-Video and Fine-Tuning-based Customizationcited by 5
- 2023Federated Continual Novel Class Learningcited by 4
- 2024MAP: MAsk-Pruning for Source-Free Model Intellectual Property Protectioncited by 4
- 2024Graph Neural Backdoor: Fundamentals, Methodologies, Applications, and Future Directionscited by 4
- 2025Vision-Language Model IP Protection via Prompt-based Learningcited by 3
- 2024IDEA: An Inverse Domain Expert Adaptation Based Active DNN IP Protection Methodcited by 2
- 2024Non-transferable Pruningcited by 2
- 2025Split Adaptation for Pre-trained Vision Transformerscited by 2
- 2025Defending Unauthorized Model Merging via Dual-Stage Weight Protectioncited by 2
- 2026Intellectual Property Protection for 3D Gaussian Splatting Assets: A Surveycited by 2
- 2024DACR: Distribution-Augmented Contrastive Reconstruction for Time-Series Anomaly Detectioncited by 1
- 2024Semantic Feature Learning for Universal Unsupervised Cross-Domain Retrievalcited by 1
- 2024ICLGuard: Controlling In-Context Learning Behavior for Applicability Authorizationcited by 1
- 2025Efficient and Privacy-Preserving Soft Prompt Transfer for LLMscited by 1
- 2025Patronus: Safeguarding Text-to-Image Models against White-Box Adversariescited by 1
- 2026How Implicit Bias Accumulates and Propagates in LLM Long-term Memorycited by 1
- 2026Immunizing 3D Gaussian Generative Models Against Unauthorized Fine-Tuning via Attribute-Space Trapscited by 1
- 2023OVLA: Neural Network Ownership Verification using Latent Watermarkscited by 0
- 2024Federated Learning with New Knowledge: Fundamentals, Advances, and Futurescited by 0
- 2025Graph in the Vault: Protecting Edge GNN Inference with Trusted Execution Environmentcited by 0
- 2025ProDiF: Protecting Domain-Invariant Features to Secure Pre-Trained Models Against Extractioncited by 0
- 2025CHIP: Chameleon Hash-based Irreversible Passport for Robust Deep Model Ownership Verification and Active Usage Controlcited by 0
- 2026Authorize-on-Demand: Dynamic Authorization with Legality-Aware Intellectual Property Protection for VLMscited by 0
50 most cited of 52 All 52 (JSON)
- 2026Positive-Unlabeled Learning for Agent Safety False Alarm Auditing2 Oct 2026
- 2026On Unlearning for Time-series Forecasting2 Oct 2026
- 2026Delving into the Temporal Challenges of Unified Video Protection Against Image-to-Video and Fine-Tuning-based Customization14 Jul 2026
- 2026Immunizing 3D Gaussian Generative Models Against Unauthorized Fine-Tuning via Attribute-Space Traps6 Apr 2026
- 2026Authorize-on-Demand: Dynamic Authorization with Legality-Aware Intellectual Property Protection for VLMs5 Mar 2026
- 2026Intellectual Property Protection for 3D Gaussian Splatting Assets: A Survey2 Feb 2026
- 2026How Implicit Bias Accumulates and Propagates in LLM Long-term Memory2 Feb 2026
- 2025AdLift: Lifting Adversarial Perturbations to Safeguard 3D Gaussian Splatting Assets Against Instruction-Driven Editing8 Dec 2025
- 2025Defending Unauthorized Model Merging via Dual-Stage Weight Protection14 Nov 2025
- 2025Patronus: Safeguarding Text-to-Image Models against White-Box Adversaries18 Oct 2025
- 2025Catch-Only-One: Non-Transferable Examples for Model-Specific Authorization13 Oct 2025
- 2025When Data-Free Knowledge Distillation Meets Non-Transferable Teacher: Escaping Out-of-Distribution Trap is All You Need5 Jul 2025
38 more
- 2025Rethinking Data Protection in the (Generative) Artificial Intelligence Era3 Jul 2025
- 2025Efficient and Privacy-Preserving Soft Prompt Transfer for LLMs19 Jun 2025
- 2025CHIP: Chameleon Hash-based Irreversible Passport for Robust Deep Model Ownership Verification and Active Usage Control30 May 2025
- 2025DuFFin: A Dual-Level Fingerprinting Framework for LLMs IP Protection22 May 2025
- 2025Jailbreaking the Non-Transferable Barrier via Test-Time Data Disguising21 Mar 2025
- 2025ProDiF: Protecting Domain-Invariant Features to Secure Pre-Trained Models Against Extraction17 Mar 2025
- 2025Vision-Language Model IP Protection via Prompt-based Learning4 Mar 2025
- 2025Split Adaptation for Pre-trained Vision Transformers1 Mar 2025
- 2025REFINE: Inversion-Free Backdoor Defense via Model Reprogramming22 Feb 2025
- 2025Graph in the Vault: Protecting Edge GNN Inference with Trusted Execution Environment20 Feb 2025
- 2025Toward Robust Non-Transferable Learning: A Survey and Benchmark19 Feb 2025
- 2024Non-transferable Pruning10 Oct 2024
- 2024IDEA: An Inverse Domain Expert Adaptation Based Active DNN IP Protection Method29 Sep 2024
- 2024Say No to Freeloader: Protecting Intellectual Property of Your Deep Model23 Aug 2024
- 2024On Large Language Model Continual Unlearning14 Jul 2024
- 2024ICLGuard: Controlling In-Context Learning Behavior for Applicability Authorization9 Jul 2024
- 2024Graph Neural Backdoor: Fundamentals, Methodologies, Applications, and Future Directions15 Jun 2024
- 2024Representation Noising: A Defence Mechanism Against Harmful Finetuning23 May 2024
- 2024SOPHON: Non-Fine-Tunable Learning to Restrain Task Transferability For Pre-trained Models19 Apr 2024
- 2024Semantic Feature Learning for Universal Unsupervised Cross-Domain Retrieval8 Mar 2024
- 2024MAP: MAsk-Pruning for Source-Free Model Intellectual Property Protection7 Mar 2024
- 2024DeepEclipse: How to Break White-Box DNN-Watermarking Schemes6 Mar 2024
- 2024Immunization against harmful fine-tuning attacks26 Feb 2024
- 2024Federated Learning with New Knowledge: Fundamentals, Advances, and Futures3 Feb 2024
- 2024DACR: Distribution-Augmented Contrastive Reconstruction for Time-Series Anomaly Detection20 Jan 2024
- 2023Reinforcement Unlearning26 Dec 2023
- 2023Federated Continual Novel Class Learning21 Dec 2023
- 2023LoRA Fine-tuning Efficiently Undoes Safety Training in Llama 2-Chat 70B31 Oct 2023
- 2023Domain Watermark: Effective and Harmless Dataset Copyright Protection is Closed at Hand9 Oct 2023
- 2023Towards Robust Model Watermark via Reducing Parametric Vulnerability9 Sep 2023
- 2023OVLA: Neural Network Ownership Verification using Latent Watermarks15 Jun 2023
- 2023Federated Incremental Semantic Segmentation10 Apr 2023
- 2023A Survey on Class Imbalance in Federated Learning21 Mar 2023
- 2023Model Barrier: A Compact Un-Transferable Isolation Domain for Model Intellectual Property Protection20 Mar 2023
- 2023The Science of Detecting LLM-Generated Texts4 Feb 2023
- 2023DEJA VU: Continual Model Generalization For Unseen Domains25 Jan 2023
- 2022Unsupervised Non-transferable Text Classification23 Oct 2022
- 2022Dataset Inference for Self-Supervised Models16 Sep 2022
50 newest of 52 All 52 (JSON)
- 2024Representation Noising: A Defence Mechanism Against Harmful Finetuningcited by 96
- 2024On Large Language Model Continual Unlearningcited by 52
- 2023Reinforcement Unlearningcited by 17
- 2023Towards Robust Model Watermark via Reducing Parametric Vulnerabilitycited by 10
- 2025Jailbreaking the Non-Transferable Barrier via Test-Time Data Disguisingcited by 8
- 2025DuFFin: A Dual-Level Fingerprinting Framework for LLMs IP Protectioncited by 8
- 2025CHIP: Chameleon Hash-based Irreversible Passport for Robust Deep Model Ownership Verification and Active Usage Controlcited by 0
- 2026On Unlearning for Time-series Forecastingcited by 0
- 2026On Unlearning for Time-series Forecasting2 Oct 2026
- 2025CHIP: Chameleon Hash-based Irreversible Passport for Robust Deep Model Ownership Verification and Active Usage Control30 May 2025
- 2025DuFFin: A Dual-Level Fingerprinting Framework for LLMs IP Protection22 May 2025
- 2025Jailbreaking the Non-Transferable Barrier via Test-Time Data Disguising21 Mar 2025
- 2024On Large Language Model Continual Unlearning14 Jul 2024
- 2024Representation Noising: A Defence Mechanism Against Harmful Finetuning23 May 2024
- 2023Reinforcement Unlearning26 Dec 2023
- 2023Towards Robust Model Watermark via Reducing Parametric Vulnerability9 Sep 2023
- 2023The Science of Detecting LLM-Generated Textscited by 128
- 2022Federated Class-Incremental Learningcited by 127
- 2023Domain Watermark: Effective and Harmless Dataset Copyright Protection is Closed at Handcited by 57
- 2022Dataset Inference for Self-Supervised Modelscited by 36
- 2023Federated Incremental Semantic Segmentationcited by 36
- 2024Immunization against harmful fine-tuning attackscited by 35
- 2025REFINE: Inversion-Free Backdoor Defense via Model Reprogrammingcited by 22
- 2022PolicyCleanse: Backdoor Detection and Mitigation in Reinforcement Learningcited by 19
- 2025Rethinking Data Protection in the (Generative) Artificial Intelligence Eracited by 18
- 2024SOPHON: Non-Fine-Tunable Learning to Restrain Task Transferability For Pre-trained Modelscited by 17
- 2023Model Barrier: A Compact Un-Transferable Isolation Domain for Model Intellectual Property Protectioncited by 14
- 2023DEJA VU: Continual Model Generalization For Unseen Domainscited by 13
12 most cited of 40 All 40 (JSON)
- 2026Delving into the Temporal Challenges of Unified Video Protection Against Image-to-Video and Fine-Tuning-based Customization14 Jul 2026
- 2026Immunizing 3D Gaussian Generative Models Against Unauthorized Fine-Tuning via Attribute-Space Traps6 Apr 2026
- 2026Authorize-on-Demand: Dynamic Authorization with Legality-Aware Intellectual Property Protection for VLMs5 Mar 2026
- 2026Intellectual Property Protection for 3D Gaussian Splatting Assets: A Survey2 Feb 2026
- 2026How Implicit Bias Accumulates and Propagates in LLM Long-term Memory2 Feb 2026
- 2025AdLift: Lifting Adversarial Perturbations to Safeguard 3D Gaussian Splatting Assets Against Instruction-Driven Editing8 Dec 2025
- 2025Defending Unauthorized Model Merging via Dual-Stage Weight Protection14 Nov 2025
- 2025Patronus: Safeguarding Text-to-Image Models against White-Box Adversaries18 Oct 2025
- 2025Catch-Only-One: Non-Transferable Examples for Model-Specific Authorization13 Oct 2025
- 2025Rethinking Data Protection in the (Generative) Artificial Intelligence Era3 Jul 2025
- 2025Efficient and Privacy-Preserving Soft Prompt Transfer for LLMs19 Jun 2025
- 2025ProDiF: Protecting Domain-Invariant Features to Secure Pre-Trained Models Against Extraction17 Mar 2025
12 newest of 40 All 40 (JSON)
Similar, not cited
Close in wording, no citation either way
- 2023ZKROWNN: Zero Knowledge Right of Ownership for Neural Networks
- 2025NWaaS: A Non-Intrusive and Privacy-Preserving Watermarking-as-a-Service System with Adaptive Resource Scheduling
- 2024Revisiting Black-Box Model Ownership Verification through Information Theory
- 2024Agentic Copyright Watermarking against Adversarial Evidence Forgery with Purification-Agnostic Curriculum Proxy Learning
- 2026Reversible Unlearnable Examples: Towards the Copyright Protection in Deep Learning Era
- 2024Generative Models are Self-Watermarked: Declaring Model Authentication through Re-Generation
- 2024Explanation as a Watermark: Towards Harmless and Multi-bit Model Ownership Verification via Watermarking Feature Attribution
- 2026T2S: A Rehearsal-Based Approach for Extraction-Resistant Model Watermarking