CAMI: Cost-Aware Agent-Guided Multi-Indexing for Semantic Retrieval

RAG ingestion pipelines frequently augment search corpus index with semantic enrichment indices (e.g., synthetic queries or summaries generated from corpus chunks) that are subsequently queried alongside the base index to improve retrieval via better alignment between document representations and user intent. While these supplementary representations substantially improve retrieval quality, they introduce a computational bottleneck: the configuration space of enrichment types and generator models is combinatorial, and the cost of exhaustive index-time evaluation scales linearly with corpus size. We introduce CAMI (Cost-Aware Multi-Indexing), a framework that formalizes multi-index construction as a budgeted, multi-objective portfolio selection problem. CAMI targets the upstream decision of which enrichment views to generate and materialize before the retrieval backend is applied. CAMI incorporates three primary mechanisms: (i) an agentic discovery phase that proposes corpus-specific representation templates; (ii) an atomic-unit search procedure that evaluates individual enrichment-model pairs and recombines them via fidelity-local closure to identify synergistic portfolios; and (iii) a confidence-aware promotion schedule that prunes unpromising configurations early, decoupling optimization spend from total corpus size. We evaluate CAMI across diverse retrieval corpora. Our findings reveal that the framework systematically isolates high-recall portfolios under strict budget constraints, outperforming standard content-only baselines in challenging settings by up to 9.4% recall@10. Further, CAMI is able to systematically identify these high-recall portfolios using up to 5x less budget compared to random search baselines, making our approach practical in real production scenarios.