The Convergence Rate of Neural Networks for Learned Functions of Different Frequencies
Not on the map. Why?
Abstract (arXiv)
We study the relationship between the frequency of a function and the speed at which a neural network learns it. We build on recent results that show that the dynamics of overparameterized neural networks trained with gradient descent can be well approximated by a linear system. When normalized training data is uniformly distributed on a hypersphere, the eigenfunctions of this linear system are spherical harmonic functions. We derive the corresponding eigenvalues for each frequency after introducing a bias term in the model. This bias term had been omitted from the linear network model without significantly affecting previous theoretical results. However, we show theoretically and experimentally that a shallow neural network without bias cannot represent or learn simple, low frequency functions with odd frequencies. Our results lead to specific predictions of the time it will take a network to learn functions of varying frequency. These predictions match the empirical behavior of both shallow and deep networks.
Key facts. Cited by 134 papers in the map (data through 7 Oct 2026). First posted on arXiv 2 Jun 2019.
Builds on
No reference list yet.
Built on by
Citing papers per year: 2021: 22; 2022: 24; 2023: 27; 2024: 29; 2025: 18; 2026: 14.
134 papers.
Sort:
By area:
- 2021COIN: COmpression with Implicit Neural representationscited by 232
- 2023Task Arithmetic in the Tangent Space: Improved Editing of Pre-Trained Modelscited by 218
- 2021Finite Basis Physics-Informed Neural Networks (FBPINNs): a scalable domain decomposition approach for solving differential equationscited by 142
- 2023An Expert's Guide to Training Physics-informed Neural Networkscited by 119
- 2022Overview frequency principle/spectral bias in deep learningcited by 68
- 2021The staircase property: How hierarchical structure can guide deep learningcited by 62
- 2021On the Frequency Bias of Generative Modelscited by 60
- 2021SAPE: Spatially-Adaptive Progressive Encoding for Neural Optimizationcited by 59
- 2024Kolmogorov-Arnold Transformercited by 56
- 2022Mitigating spectral bias for the multiscale operator learningcited by 43
- 2021Quadratic Residual Networks: A New Class of Neural Networks for Solving Forward and Inverse Problems in Physics Involving PDEscited by 42
- 2021Spectral Bias in Practice: The Role of Function Frequency in Generalizationcited by 36
38 more
- 2024Improved Implicit Neural Representation with Fourier Reparameterized Trainingcited by 36
- 2024On the expressiveness and spectral bias of KANscited by 36
- 2022DINER: Disorder-Invariant Implicit Neural Representationcited by 30
- 2023On the Eigenvalue Decay Rates of a Class of Neural-Network Related Kernel Functions Defined on General Domainscited by 30
- 2023Don't blame Dataset Shift! Shortcut Learning due to Gradients and Cross Entropycited by 30
- 2021Deep Neural Networks as Point Estimates for Deep Gaussian Processescited by 26
- 2023Simplicity Bias in 1-Hidden Layer Neural Networkscited by 26
- 2023Disorder-invariant Implicit Neural Representationcited by 26
- 2023Generalization in Kernel Regression Under Realistic Assumptionscited by 26
- 2022Incremental Spatial and Spectral Learning of Neural Operators for Solving Large-Scale PDEscited by 25
- 2022Implicit regularization of dropoutcited by 24
- 2022Theoretical Perspectives on Deep Learning Methods in Inverse Problemscited by 22
- 2022Characterizing the Spectrum of the NTK via a Power Series Expansioncited by 22
- 2021Uniform Generalization Bounds for Overparameterized Neural Networkscited by 21
- 2022Finite Expression Method for Solving High-Dimensional Partial Differential Equationscited by 21
- 2022What Can the Neural Tangent Kernel Tell Us About Adversarial Robustness?cited by 21
- 2021Spectral Analysis of the Neural Tangent Kernel for Deep Residual Networkscited by 20
- 2022The Spectral Bias of Polynomial Neural Networkscited by 19
- 2022Overcoming the Spectral Bias of Neural Value Approximationcited by 18
- 2021Functional Regularization for Reinforcement Learning via Learned Fourier Featurescited by 17
- 2021Shift Invariance Can Reduce Adversarial Robustnesscited by 16
- 2024Tuning Frequency Bias of State Space Modelscited by 16
- 2022On the Spectral Bias of Convolutional Neural Tangent and Gaussian Process Kernelscited by 15
- 2023Loss Spike in Training Neural Networkscited by 15
- 2021Learning curves for Gaussian process regression with power-law priors and targetscited by 14
- 2023Machine learning and domain decomposition methods -- a surveycited by 14
- 2024FreSh: Frequency Shifting for Accelerated Neural Representation Learningcited by 14
- 2024Addressing Spectral Bias of Deep Neural Networks by Multi-Grade Deep Learningcited by 14
- 2021On the Generalization Power of Overfitted Two-Layer Neural Tangent Kernel Modelscited by 13
- 2023Partition Speeds Up Learning Implicit Neural Representations Based on Exponential-Increase Hypothesiscited by 13
- 2024Towards Understanding Inductive Bias in Transformers: A View From Infinitycited by 13
- 2024Transformers Learn Low Sensitivity Functions: Investigations and Implicationscited by 13
- 2024Bounds for the smallest eigenvalue of the NTK for arbitrary spherical data of arbitrary dimensioncited by 13
- 2022Spectral Bias Outside the Training Set for Deep Networks in the Kernel Regimecited by 11
- 2024Fast Training of Sinusoidal Neural Fields via Scaling Initializationcited by 11
- 2021Exploring The Effect of High-frequency Components in GANs Trainingcited by 10
- 2021Principal Components Bias in Over-parameterized Linear Models, and its Manifestation in Deep Neural Networkscited by 10
- 2021Subspace Decomposition based DNN algorithm for elliptic type multi-scale PDEscited by 10
50 most cited of 134 All 134 (JSON)
- 2026Latent-MoE: Domain-Aware Mixture-of-Experts for PDEs with Multi-Regime Physics7 Sep 2026
- 2026See the Change, Keep the Flow: Unsupervised Action Segmentation via Spectral-Temporal Representation Learning30 Aug 2026
- 2026SpiS-GAN: Spiral-Modulated Handwriting Synthesis with Star Operation8 Jul 2026
- 2026A Function-Space Dichotomy for Compositional Learning: Exponential Sub-Optimality of the Neural Tangent Kernel7 Jul 2026
- 2026Position: Don't Just "Fix it in Post": A Science of AI Must Study Training Dynamics3 Jun 2026
- 2026Low-Frequency Shortcuts in Texture-Driven Visual Learning2 Jun 2026
- 2026Revisiting Neural Processes via Fourier Transform and Volterra Series31 May 2026
- 2026Colored Noise Diffusion Sampling28 May 2026
- 2026Label-NTK Alignments and A Tighter Convergence Bound in the NTK Regime24 May 2026
- 2026Spectral Energy Centroid: a Metric for Improving Performance and Analyzing Spectral Bias in Implicit Neural Representations12 May 2026
- 2026Residual-as-Teacher: Mitigating Bias Propagation in Student--Teacher Estimation26 Mar 2026
- 2026Plug, Play, and Fortify: A Low-Cost Module for Robust Multimodal Image Understanding Models26 Feb 2026
38 more
- 2026Gradient Residual Connections9 Feb 2026
- 2026Shortcut Features as Top Eigenfunctions of NTK: A Linear Neural Network Case and More3 Feb 2026
- 2025SONAR: Spectral-Contrastive Audio Residuals for Generalizable Deepfake Detection26 Nov 2025
- 2025SURFing to the Fundamental Limit of Jet Tagging19 Nov 2025
- 2025Overconfident and Blind to Details: Fixing Prompt Insensitivity with Abductive Preference Learning10 Oct 2025
- 2025Training Variation of Physically-Informed Deep Learning Models3 Oct 2025
- 2025Spectral Bottleneck in Sinusoidal Representation Networks: Noise is All You Need9 Sep 2025
- 2025SBS: Enhancing Parameter-Efficiency of Neural Representations for Neural Networks via Spectral Bias Suppression9 Sep 2025
- 2025FW-GAN: Frequency-Driven Handwriting Synthesis with Wave-Modulated MLP Generator28 Aug 2025
- 2025Spectral Bias in Variational Quantum Machine Learning27 Jun 2025
- 2025Beyond ReLU: How Activations Affect Neural Kernels and Random Wide Networks27 Jun 2025
- 2025Model Reprogramming Demystified: A Neural Tangent Kernel Perspective31 May 2025
- 2025Block-Biased Mamba for Long-Range Sequence Processing13 May 2025
- 2025How Learnable Grids Recover Fine Detail in Low Dimensions: A Neural Tangent Kernel Analysis of Multigrid Parametric Encodings18 Apr 2025
- 2025DeepOHeat-v1: Efficient Operator Learning for Fast and Trustworthy Thermal Simulation and Optimization in 3D-IC Design4 Apr 2025
- 2025Neural Tangent Kernel of Neural Networks with Loss Informed by Differential Operators14 Mar 2025
- 2025Worth Their Weight: Randomized and Regularized Block Kaczmarz Algorithms without Preprocessing2 Feb 2025
- 2025On the study of frequency control and spectral bias in Wavelet-Based Kolmogorov Arnold networks: A path to physics-informed KANs1 Feb 2025
- 2025A Deep State Space Model for Rainfall-Runoff Simulations24 Jan 2025
- 2025SNeRV: Spectra-preserving Neural Representation for Video3 Jan 2025
- 2024Solving Partial Differential Equations with Random Feature Models31 Dec 2024
- 2024RoDyGS: Robust Dynamic Gaussian Splatting for Casual Videos4 Dec 2024
- 2024Predicting the Encoding Error of SIRENs29 Oct 2024
- 2024Addressing Spectral Bias of Deep Neural Networks by Multi-Grade Deep Learning21 Oct 2024
- 2024Inductive Gradient Adjustment For Spectral Bias In Implicit Neural Representations17 Oct 2024
- 2024Geometric Inductive Biases of Deep Networks: The Role of Data and Architecture15 Oct 2024
- 2024Quantifying Training Difficulty and Accelerating Convergence in Neural Network-Based PDE Solvers8 Oct 2024
- 2024SHAP values via sparse Fourier representation8 Oct 2024
- 2024FreSh: Frequency Shifting for Accelerated Neural Representation Learning7 Oct 2024
- 2024Fast Training of Sinusoidal Neural Fields via Scaling Initialization7 Oct 2024
- 2024Tuning Frequency Bias of State Space Models2 Oct 2024
- 2024On the expressiveness and spectral bias of KANs2 Oct 2024
- 2024Kolmogorov-Arnold Transformer16 Sep 2024
- 2024Dilated convolution neural operator for multiscale partial differential equations16 Jul 2024
- 2024When Are Bias-Free ReLU Networks Effectively Linear Networks?18 Jun 2024
- 2024Demystifying Spectral Bias on Real-World Data4 Jun 2024
- 2024Can Kernel Methods Explain How the Data Affects Neural Collapse?4 Jun 2024
- 2024A rationale from frequency perspective for grokking in training neural network24 May 2024
50 newest of 134 All 134 (JSON)
- 2026Colored Noise Diffusion Samplingcited by 1
- 2026Colored Noise Diffusion Sampling28 May 2026
- 2025Block-Biased Mamba for Long-Range Sequence Processingcited by 7
- 2025Block-Biased Mamba for Long-Range Sequence Processing13 May 2025
- 2021COIN: COmpression with Implicit Neural representationscited by 232
- 2023Task Arithmetic in the Tangent Space: Improved Editing of Pre-Trained Modelscited by 218
- 2021Finite Basis Physics-Informed Neural Networks (FBPINNs): a scalable domain decomposition approach for solving differential equationscited by 142
- 2023An Expert's Guide to Training Physics-informed Neural Networkscited by 119
- 2022Overview frequency principle/spectral bias in deep learningcited by 68
- 2021The staircase property: How hierarchical structure can guide deep learningcited by 62
- 2021On the Frequency Bias of Generative Modelscited by 60
- 2021SAPE: Spatially-Adaptive Progressive Encoding for Neural Optimizationcited by 59
- 2024Kolmogorov-Arnold Transformercited by 56
- 2022Mitigating spectral bias for the multiscale operator learningcited by 43
- 2021Quadratic Residual Networks: A New Class of Neural Networks for Solving Forward and Inverse Problems in Physics Involving PDEscited by 42
- 2021Spectral Bias in Practice: The Role of Function Frequency in Generalizationcited by 36
12 most cited of 130 All 130 (JSON)
- 2026See the Change, Keep the Flow: Unsupervised Action Segmentation via Spectral-Temporal Representation Learning30 Aug 2026
- 2026SpiS-GAN: Spiral-Modulated Handwriting Synthesis with Star Operation8 Jul 2026
- 2026A Function-Space Dichotomy for Compositional Learning: Exponential Sub-Optimality of the Neural Tangent Kernel7 Jul 2026
- 2026Position: Don't Just "Fix it in Post": A Science of AI Must Study Training Dynamics3 Jun 2026
- 2026Low-Frequency Shortcuts in Texture-Driven Visual Learning2 Jun 2026
- 2026Revisiting Neural Processes via Fourier Transform and Volterra Series31 May 2026
- 2026Label-NTK Alignments and A Tighter Convergence Bound in the NTK Regime24 May 2026
- 2026Spectral Energy Centroid: a Metric for Improving Performance and Analyzing Spectral Bias in Implicit Neural Representations12 May 2026
- 2026Residual-as-Teacher: Mitigating Bias Propagation in Student--Teacher Estimation26 Mar 2026
- 2026Plug, Play, and Fortify: A Low-Cost Module for Robust Multimodal Image Understanding Models26 Feb 2026
- 2026Gradient Residual Connections9 Feb 2026
- 2026Shortcut Features as Top Eigenfunctions of NTK: A Linear Neural Network Case and More3 Feb 2026
12 newest of 130 All 130 (JSON)