Consistent Distributed Ranking of Generative Models via Kernel Distances

Ranking generative models based on the fidelity and diversity of their outputs is required to identify the best generator in a group of candidate generative AI models. To rank a group of models in a conventional centralized setting, a standard score is commonly evaluated for each involved model. The selection and design of reference-based evaluation scores have been extensively studied in centralized settings, where the reference samples are drawn from a single probability distribution. However, in practical scenarios including distributed learning contexts, reference samples are distributed across multiple clients, each potentially with a heterogeneous data distribution. In this work, we investigate the ranking of generative models in such distributed settings with heterogeneous data distributions across clients. We focus on the widely used family of kernel distance (KD) evaluation metrics. We prove that, for every kernel function, ranking models by the averaged KD scores of individual clients yields the same ordering as a centralized KD evaluation using the combined reference data from all the clients. We further extend our analysis to other popular metrics, including the Fr'echet Distance (FD), for which the individual client scores could be insufficient for accurate model ranking. We present the numerical results of several experiments on standard image datasets and generative models to validate our theoretical findings regarding distributed ranking using various evaluation scores.