Investigating Bi-Level Optimization for Learning and Vision from a Unified Perspective: A Survey and Beyond
Not on the map. Why?
Abstract (arXiv)
Bi-Level Optimization (BLO) is originated from the area of economic game theory and then introduced into the optimization community. BLO is able to handle problems with a hierarchical structure, involving two levels of optimization tasks, where one task is nested inside the other. In machine learning and computer vision fields, despite the different motivations and mechanisms, a lot of complex problems, such as hyper-parameter optimization, multi-task and meta-learning, neural architecture search, adversarial learning and deep reinforcement learning, actually all contain a series of closely related subproblms. In this paper, we first uniformly express these complex learning and vision problems from the perspective of BLO. Then we construct a best-response-based single-level reformulation and establish a unified algorithmic framework to understand and formulate mainstream gradient-based BLO methodologies, covering aspects ranging from fundamental automatic differentiation schemes to various accelerations, simplifications, extensions and their convergence and complexity properties. Last but not least, we discuss the potentials of our unified BLO framework for designing new algorithms and point out some promising directions for future research.
Key facts. Cited by 151 papers in the map (data through 7 Oct 2026). Builds on 137 of its 268 references that are in the map. First posted on arXiv 27 Jan 2021.
Builds on
137 of 268 references.
References · 137
- 2017Model-Agnostic Meta-Learning for Fast Adaptation of Deep Networkscited by 4,861
- 2018DARTS: Differentiable Architecture Searchcited by 1,782
- 2016Generative Adversarial Imitation Learningcited by 1,576
- 2018On First-Order Meta-Learning Algorithmscited by 1,003
- 2015Automatic differentiation in machine learning: a surveycited by 846
- 2018Efficient Neural Architecture Search via Parameter Sharingcited by 831
- 2017An Overview of Multi-Task Learning in Deep Neural Networkscited by 791
- 2018Image Transformercited by 770
- 2019Self-supervised Visual Feature Learning with Deep Neural Networks: A Surveycited by 656
- 2016Learning to learn by gradient descent by gradient descentcited by 616
- 2017OptNet: Differentiable Optimization as a Layer in Neural Networkscited by 588
- 2019Meta-Learning with Implicit Gradientscited by 523
38 more
- 2018Meta-Learning with Latent Embedding Optimizationcited by 476
- 2018Bilevel Programming for Hyperparameter Optimization and Meta-Learningcited by 403
- 2018Meta-learning with differentiable closed-form solverscited by 395
- 2018Dynamic Few-Shot Visual Learning without Forgettingcited by 385
- 2017Meta-SGD: Learning to Learn Quickly for Few-Shot Learningcited by 377
- 2016Learning to reinforcement learncited by 369
- 2019Rapid Learning or Feature Reuse? Towards Understanding the Effectiveness of MAMLcited by 359
- 2015Gradient-based Hyperparameter Optimization through Reversible Learningcited by 357
- 2018How to train your MAMLcited by 306
- 2019Optimizing Millions of Hyperparameters by Implicit Differentiationcited by 303
- 2020Retinex-inspired Unrolling with Cooperative Prior Architecture Search for Low-light Image Enhancementcited by 303
- 2018SNAS: Stochastic Neural Architecture Searchcited by 288
- 2017Meta Networkscited by 268
- 2019PC-DARTS: Partial Channel Connections for Memory-Efficient Architecture Searchcited by 265
- 2019Adversarial Attacks on Graph Neural Networks via Meta Learningcited by 261
- 2019Auto-DeepLab: Hierarchical Neural Architecture Search for Semantic Image Segmentationcited by 258
- 2017Forward and Reverse Gradient-Based Hyperparameter Optimizationcited by 232
- 2016Hyperparameter optimization with approximate gradientcited by 231
- 2018Approximation Methods for Bilevel Programmingcited by 231
- 2019Progressive Differentiable Architecture Search: Bridging the Depth Gap between Search and Evaluationcited by 230
- 2020Mnemonics Training: Multi-Class Incremental Learning without Forgettingcited by 220
- 2020Bilevel Optimization: Convergence Analysis and Enhanced Designcited by 219
- 2017The Reversible Residual Network: Backpropagation Without Storing Activationscited by 215
- 2016Unrolled Generative Adversarial Networkscited by 208
- 2017Beyond Finite Layer Neural Networks: Bridging Deep Architectures and Numerical Differential Equationscited by 203
- 2016Learning to Optimizecited by 195
- 2020Coresets via Bilevel Optimization for Continual Learning and Streamingcited by 191
- 2018Truncated Back-propagation for Bilevel Optimizationcited by 187
- 2018Generative Adversarial Imitation from Observationcited by 183
- 2019Meta-SR: A Magnification-Arbitrary Network for Super-Resolutioncited by 180
- 2018Meta-Gradient Reinforcement Learningcited by 156
- 2020On the Iteration Complexity of Hypergradient Computationcited by 154
- 2019On the Convergence Theory of Gradient-Based Model-Agnostic Meta-Learning Algorithmscited by 132
- 2017A Review on Bilevel Optimization: From Classical to Evolutionary Approaches and Applicationscited by 126
- 2017Few-Shot Image Recognition by Predicting Parameters from Activationscited by 122
- 2017Online Learning Rate Adaptation with Hypergradient Descentcited by 117
- 2020Meta-Transfer Learning for Zero-Shot Super-Resolutioncited by 116
- 2016On Differentiating Parameterized Argmin and Argmax Problems with Application to Bi-level Optimizationcited by 108
50 most cited of 137 All 137 (JSON)
Built on by
Citing papers per year: 2021: 16; 2022: 27; 2023: 47; 2024: 30; 2025: 18; 2026: 13.
151 papers.
Sort:
By area:
- 2022Target-aware Dual Adversarial Learning and a Multi-scenario Multi-Modality Benchmark to Fuse Infrared and Visible for Object Detectioncited by 313
- 2023Multi-interactive Feature Learning and a Full-time Multi-modality Benchmark for Image Fusion and Segmentationcited by 128
- 2021A Near-Optimal Algorithm for Stochastic Bilevel Optimization via Double-Momentumcited by 106
- 2022Equivariance with Learned Canonicalization Functionscited by 106
- 2022BOME! Bilevel Optimization Made Easy: A Simple First-Order Approachcited by 103
- 2022Physics-Informed Machine Learning: A Survey on Problems, Methods and Applicationscited by 88
- 2023On Penalty-based Bilevel Gradient Descent Methodcited by 87
- 2022Unsupervised Misaligned Infrared and Visible Image Fusion via Cross-Modality Image Generation and Registrationcited by 80
- 2022Untargeted Backdoor Watermark: Towards Harmless and Stealthy Dataset Copyright Protectioncited by 80
- 2021Is Attention Better Than Matrix Decomposition?cited by 75
- 2024Diffusion Models in Low-Level Vision: A Surveycited by 73
- 2021A Single-Timescale Method for Stochastic Bilevel Optimizationcited by 69
38 more
- 2022Boosting the Transferability of Adversarial Attacks with Reverse Adversarial Perturbationcited by 67
- 2021Towards Gradient-based Bilevel Optimization with Non-convex Followers and Beyondcited by 62
- 2021Amortized Implicit Differentiation for Stochastic Bilevel Optimizationcited by 62
- 2021A Value-Function-based Interior-point Method for Non-convex Bi-level Optimizationcited by 60
- 2022FedNest: Federated Bilevel, Minimax, and Compositional Optimizationcited by 60
- 2024"Glue pizza and eat rocks" -- Exploiting Vulnerabilities in Retrieval-Augmented Generative Modelscited by 60
- 2021A Fully Single Loop Algorithm for Bilevel Optimization without Hessian Inversecited by 53
- 2023M3D: Dataset Condensation by Minimizing Maximum Mean Discrepancycited by 49
- 2023A Task-guided, Implicitly-searched and Meta-initialized Deep Model for Image Fusioncited by 47
- 2023First-order penalty methods for bilevel optimizationcited by 40
- 2023An Introduction to Bi-level Optimization: Foundations and Applications in Signal Processing and Machine Learningcited by 39
- 2023Learning to Augment Distributions for Out-of-Distribution Detectioncited by 38
- 2023Neural Preset for Color Style Transfercited by 36
- 2021BiAdam: Fast Adaptive Bilevel Optimization Methodscited by 33
- 2021On the Convergence Theory for Hessian-Free Bilevel Algorithmscited by 33
- 2022On Learning Fairness and Accuracy on Multiple Subgroupscited by 31
- 2023Robust Mixture-of-Expert Training for Convolutional Neural Networkscited by 30
- 2024Fake It till You Make It: Curricular Dynamic Forgery Augmentations towards General Deepfake Detectioncited by 30
- 2021A General Descent Aggregation Framework for Gradient-based Bi-level Optimizationcited by 28
- 2021Enhanced Bilevel Optimization via Bregman Distancecited by 28
- 2021A Bi-Level Framework for Learning to Solve Combinatorial Optimization on Graphscited by 26
- 2023Averaged Method of Multipliers for Bi-Level Optimization without Lower-Level Strong Convexitycited by 26
- 2023Bi-level Dynamic Learning for Jointly Multi-modality Image Fusion and Beyondcited by 26
- 2023PAIF: Perception-Aware Infrared-Visible Image Fusion for Attack-Tolerant Semantic Segmentationcited by 26
- 2021Value-Function-based Sequential Minimization for Bi-level Optimizationcited by 24
- 2023Q-DETR: An Efficient Low-Bit Quantized Detection Transformercited by 23
- 2023FairTune: Optimizing Parameter Efficient Fine Tuning for Fairness in Medical Image Analysiscited by 23
- 2023Bilevel Fast Scene Adaptation for Low-Light Image Enhancementcited by 22
- 2022Local Stochastic Bilevel Optimization with Momentum-Based Variance Reductioncited by 20
- 2024Functional Bilevel Optimization for Machine Learningcited by 20
- 2024AutoScale: Scale-Aware Data Mixing for Pre-Training LLMscited by 20
- 2024DELT: A Simple Diversity-driven EarlyLate Training for Dataset Distillationcited by 20
- 2023From Text to Pixels: A Context-Aware Semantic Synergy Solution for Infrared and Visible Image Fusioncited by 19
- 2022Bi-level Physics-Informed Neural Networks for PDE Constrained Optimization using Broyden's Hypergradientscited by 17
- 2022How to Sift Out a Clean Data Subset in the Presence of Data Poisoning?cited by 17
- 2024Constrained Bi-Level Optimization: Proximal Lagrangian Value function Approach and Hessian-free Algorithmcited by 16
- 2024Imperative Learning: A Self-supervised Neuro-Symbolic Learning Framework for Robot Autonomycited by 16
- 2023Efficient Gradient Approximation Method for Constrained Bilevel Optimizationcited by 15
50 most cited of 151 All 151 (JSON)
- 2026To Solve Bilevel Optimization with Nonconvex Lower Levels, We Need Second-Order Stationarity24 Sep 2026
- 2026Bilevel Optimization of Topology and Hyperparameters (BOTH)18 Sep 2026
- 2026Efficient Hessian-Free Methods for Multi-Objective Bilevel Optimization with Nonconvex Lower Level13 Aug 2026
- 2026Learning with Bilevel-Minimax Optimization for Efficient and Reliable Transfer Attacks12 Aug 2026
- 2026Bi-Level Collaborative Learning for Few-Shot Scribble-Supervised Medical Image Segmentation28 Jul 2026
- 2026Stealthy World Model Manipulation via Data Poisoning17 Jun 2026
- 2026World-Task Factorization for Robot Learning1 Jun 2026
- 2026Diffuse to Detect: Bi-Level Sample Rebalancing with Pseudo-Label Diffusion for Point-Supervised Infrared Small-Target Detection20 May 2026
- 2026CHAL: Council of Hierarchical Agentic Language12 May 2026
- 2026Generalization Guarantees on Data-Driven Tuning of Gradient Descent with Langevin Updates13 Apr 2026
- 2026Scaling GraphLLM with Bilevel-Optimized Sparse Querying30 Jan 2026
- 2026BLO-Inst: Bi-Level Optimization Based Alignment of YOLO and SAM for Robust Instance Segmentation29 Jan 2026
38 more
- 2026MetaToolAgent: Towards Generalizable Tool Usage in LLMs through Meta-Learning19 Jan 2026
- 2025Learning to learn skill assessment for fetal ultrasound scanning30 Dec 2025
- 2025Embodied Co-Design for Rapidly Evolving Agents: Taxonomy, Frontiers, and Challenges4 Dec 2025
- 2025Lower Complexity Bounds for Nonconvex-Strongly-Convex Bilevel Optimization with First-Order Oracles24 Nov 2025
- 2025Solving bilevel optimization via sequential minimax optimization10 Nov 2025
- 2025A Single-Loop First-Order Algorithm for Linearly Constrained Bilevel Optimization28 Oct 2025
- 2025BioAutoML-NAS: An End-to-End AutoML Framework for Multimodal Insect Classification via Neural Architecture Search on Large-Scale Biodiversity Data7 Oct 2025
- 2025FUSAR-KLIP: Towards Multimodal Foundation Models for Remote Sensing28 Sep 2025
- 2025Heterogeneous Self-Supervised Acoustic Pre-Training with Local Constraints27 Aug 2025
- 2025Synergistic Localization and Sensing in MIMO-OFDM Systems via Mixed-Integer Bilevel Learning7 Jul 2025
- 2025UrbanMind: Towards Urban General Intelligence via Tool-Enhanced Retrieval-Augmented Generation and Multilevel Optimization7 Jul 2025
- 2025Direct Prediction Set Minimization via Bilevel Conformal Classifier Training7 Jun 2025
- 2025CR-BLEA: Contrastive Ranking for Adaptive Resource Allocation in Bilevel Evolutionary Algorithms3 Jun 2025
- 2025Bi-Level Unsupervised Feature Selection26 May 2025
- 2025Masked Subspace Clustering Methods11 May 2025
- 2025A stochastic gradient method for trilevel optimization11 May 2025
- 2025Scalable Meta-Learning via Mixed-Mode Differentiation1 May 2025
- 2025CoA: Towards Real Image Dehazing via Compression-and-Adaptation8 Apr 2025
- 2025Towards Multimodal Metaphor Understanding: A Chinese Dataset and Model for Metaphor Mapping Identification5 Jan 2025
- 2024DELT: A Simple Diversity-driven EarlyLate Training for Dataset Distillation29 Nov 2024
- 2024Theory-inspired Label Shift Adaptation via Aligned Distribution Mixture4 Nov 2024
- 2024MADOD: Generalizing OOD Detection to Unseen Domains via G-Invariance Meta-Learning2 Nov 2024
- 2024Theoretical Investigations and Practical Enhancements on Tail Task Risk Minimization in Meta Learning30 Oct 2024
- 2024Soft-Label Integration for Robust Toxicity Classification18 Oct 2024
- 2024AutoAL: Automated Active Learning with Differentiable Query Strategy Search17 Oct 2024
- 2024Towards Differentiable Multilevel Optimization: A Gradient-Based Approach15 Oct 2024
- 2024Fake It till You Make It: Curricular Dynamic Forgery Augmentations towards General Deepfake Detection22 Sep 2024
- 2024AutoScale: Scale-Aware Data Mixing for Pre-Training LLMs29 Jul 2024
- 2024Optimal Hessian/Jacobian-Free Nonconvex-PL Bilevel Optimization25 Jul 2024
- 2024"Glue pizza and eat rocks" -- Exploiting Vulnerabilities in Retrieval-Augmented Generative Models26 Jun 2024
- 2024Imperative Learning: A Self-supervised Neuro-Symbolic Learning Framework for Robot Autonomy23 Jun 2024
- 2024Diffusion Models in Low-Level Vision: A Survey17 Jun 2024
- 2024Learning Reward and Policy Jointly from Demonstration and Preference Improves Alignment11 Jun 2024
- 2024DANCE: Dual-View Distribution Alignment for Dataset Condensation3 Jun 2024
- 2024Bilevel reinforcement learning via the development of hyper-gradient without lower-level convexity30 May 2024
- 2024Moreau Envelope for Nonconvex Bi-Level Optimization: A Single-loop and Hessian-free Solution Strategy16 May 2024
- 2024Pretrained Optimization Model for Zero-Shot Black Box Optimization6 May 2024
- 2024DeepMpMRI: Tensor-decomposition Regularized Learning for Fast and High-Fidelity Multi-Parametric Microstructural MR Imaging6 May 2024
50 newest of 151 All 151 (JSON)
- 2024Diffusion Models in Low-Level Vision: A Surveycited by 73
- 2024Diffusion Models in Low-Level Vision: A Survey17 Jun 2024
- 2026CHAL: Council of Hierarchical Agentic Languagecited by 0
- 2026CHAL: Council of Hierarchical Agentic Language12 May 2026
- 2026Stealthy World Model Manipulation via Data Poisoningcited by 2
- 2026Stealthy World Model Manipulation via Data Poisoning17 Jun 2026
- 2022Target-aware Dual Adversarial Learning and a Multi-scenario Multi-Modality Benchmark to Fuse Infrared and Visible for Object Detectioncited by 313
- 2023Multi-interactive Feature Learning and a Full-time Multi-modality Benchmark for Image Fusion and Segmentationcited by 128
- 2021A Near-Optimal Algorithm for Stochastic Bilevel Optimization via Double-Momentumcited by 106
- 2022Equivariance with Learned Canonicalization Functionscited by 106
- 2022BOME! Bilevel Optimization Made Easy: A Simple First-Order Approachcited by 103
- 2022Physics-Informed Machine Learning: A Survey on Problems, Methods and Applicationscited by 88
- 2023On Penalty-based Bilevel Gradient Descent Methodcited by 87
- 2022Unsupervised Misaligned Infrared and Visible Image Fusion via Cross-Modality Image Generation and Registrationcited by 80
- 2022Untargeted Backdoor Watermark: Towards Harmless and Stealthy Dataset Copyright Protectioncited by 80
- 2021Is Attention Better Than Matrix Decomposition?cited by 75
- 2021A Single-Timescale Method for Stochastic Bilevel Optimizationcited by 69
- 2022Boosting the Transferability of Adversarial Attacks with Reverse Adversarial Perturbationcited by 67
12 most cited of 137 All 137 (JSON)
- 2026To Solve Bilevel Optimization with Nonconvex Lower Levels, We Need Second-Order Stationarity24 Sep 2026
- 2026Bilevel Optimization of Topology and Hyperparameters (BOTH)18 Sep 2026
- 2026Efficient Hessian-Free Methods for Multi-Objective Bilevel Optimization with Nonconvex Lower Level13 Aug 2026
- 2026Learning with Bilevel-Minimax Optimization for Efficient and Reliable Transfer Attacks12 Aug 2026
- 2026Bi-Level Collaborative Learning for Few-Shot Scribble-Supervised Medical Image Segmentation28 Jul 2026
- 2026World-Task Factorization for Robot Learning1 Jun 2026
- 2026Diffuse to Detect: Bi-Level Sample Rebalancing with Pseudo-Label Diffusion for Point-Supervised Infrared Small-Target Detection20 May 2026
- 2026Generalization Guarantees on Data-Driven Tuning of Gradient Descent with Langevin Updates13 Apr 2026
- 2026Scaling GraphLLM with Bilevel-Optimized Sparse Querying30 Jan 2026
- 2026BLO-Inst: Bi-Level Optimization Based Alignment of YOLO and SAM for Robust Instance Segmentation29 Jan 2026
- 2025Learning to learn skill assessment for fetal ultrasound scanning30 Dec 2025
- 2025Embodied Co-Design for Rapidly Evolving Agents: Taxonomy, Frontiers, and Challenges4 Dec 2025
12 newest of 137 All 137 (JSON)