Product-based Neural Networks for User Response Prediction over Multi-field Categorical Data
Not on the map. Why?
Abstract (arXiv)
User response prediction is a crucial component for personalized information retrieval and filtering scenarios, such as recommender system and web search. The data in user response prediction is mostly in a multi-field categorical format and transformed into sparse representations via one-hot encoding. Due to the sparsity problems in representation and optimization, most research focuses on feature engineering and shallow modeling. Recently, deep neural networks have attracted research attention on such a problem for their high capacity and end-to-end training scheme. In this paper, we study user response prediction in the scenario of click prediction. We first analyze a coupled gradient issue in latent vector-based models and propose kernel product to learn field-aware feature interactions. Then we discuss an insensitive gradient issue in DNN-based models and propose Product-based Neural Network (PNN) which adopts a feature extractor to explore feature interactions. Generalizing the kernel product to a net-in-net architecture, we further propose Product-network In Network (PIN) which can generalize previous models. Extensive experiments on 4 industrial datasets and 1 contest dataset demonstrate that our models consistently outperform 8 baselines on both AUC and log loss. Besides, PIN makes great CTR improvement (relatively 34.67%) in online A/B test.
Key facts. Cited by 44 papers in the map (data through 7 Oct 2026). First posted on arXiv 1 Jul 2018.
Builds on
No reference list yet.
Built on by
Citing papers per year: 2021: 13; 2022: 7; 2023: 14; 2024: 5; 2025: 4; 2026: 1.
44 papers.
Sort:
By area:
- 2021Deep Learning for Click-Through Rate Estimationcited by 33
- 2022Towards Understanding the Overfitting Phenomenon of Deep Click-Through Rate Prediction Modelscited by 33
- 2023ClickPrompt: CTR Models are Strong Prompt Generators for Adapting Language Models to CTR Predictioncited by 27
- 2021TabGNN: Multiplex Graph Neural Network for Tabular Data Predictioncited by 26
- 2021ARM-Net: Adaptive Relation Modeling Network for Structured Datacited by 24
- 2023GFS: Graph-based Feature Synthesis for Prediction over Relational Databasescited by 16
- 2021User Response Prediction in Online Advertisingcited by 15
- 2023Hiformer: Heterogeneous Feature Interactions Learning with Transformers for Recommender Systemscited by 14
- 2021ScaleFreeCTR: MixCache-based Distributed Training System for CTR Models with Huge Embedding Tablecited by 12
- 2021Memorize, Factorize, or be Na"ive: Learning Optimal Feature Interaction Methods for CTR Predictioncited by 12
- 2023MAP: A Model-agnostic Pretraining Framework for Click-through Rate Predictioncited by 10
- 2023VFLAIR: A Research Library and Benchmark for Vertical Federated Learningcited by 8
32 more
- 2021XCrossNet: Feature Structure-Oriented Learning for Click-Through Rate Predictioncited by 6
- 2022Learning Enhanced Representations for Tabular Data via Neighborhood Propagationcited by 6
- 2021Muddling Label Regularization: Deep Learning for Tabular Datasetscited by 5
- 2022i-Razor: A Differentiable Neural Input Razor for Feature Selection and Dimension Search in DNN-Based Recommender Systemscited by 4
- 2022A Comprehensive Survey on Automated Machine Learning for Recommendationscited by 4
- 2025Revisiting Feature Interactions from the Perspective of Quadratic Neural Networks for Click-through Rate Predictioncited by 3
- 2021Task-wise Split Gradient Boosting Trees for Multi-center Diabetes Predictioncited by 2
- 2021Secure Your Ride: Real-time Matching Success Rate Prediction for Passenger-Driver Pairscited by 2
- 2021AEFE: Automatic Embedded Feature Engineering for Categorical Featurescited by 2
- 2022On-Device Model Fine-Tuning with Label Correction in Recommender Systemscited by 2
- 2023xDeepInt: a hybrid architecture for modeling the vector-wise and bit-wise feature interactionscited by 2
- 2023Exploiting Field Dependencies for Learning on Categorical Datacited by 2
- 2023Towards Hybrid-grained Feature Interaction Selection for Deep Sparse Networkcited by 2
- 2023From Principle to Practice: Vertical Data Minimization for Machine Learningcited by 2
- 2024DisCo: Towards Harmonious Disentanglement and Collaboration between Tabular and Semantic Space for Recommendationcited by 2
- 2021MOEF: Modeling Occasion Evolution in Frequency Domain for Promotion-Aware Click-Through Rate Predictioncited by 1
- 2022Directed Acyclic Graph Factorization Machines for CTR Prediction via Knowledge Distillationcited by 1
- 2023AdaEnsemble: Learning Adaptively Sparse Structured Ensemble Network for Click-Through Rate Predictioncited by 1
- 2023ROMO: Retrieval-enhanced Offline Model-based Optimizationcited by 1
- 2024Retrieval and Distill: A Temporal Data Shift-Free Paradigm for Online Recommendation Systemcited by 1
- 2024Retrieval-Oriented Knowledge for Click-Through Rate Predictioncited by 1
- 2025Target-Aware Early Stage Rankingcited by 1
- 2021Online Interaction Detection for Click-Through Rate Predictioncited by 0
- 2022Risk-Aware Bid Optimization for Online Display Advertisementcited by 0
- 2023DynInt: Dynamic Interaction Modeling for Large-scale Click-Through Rate Predictioncited by 0
- 2023DELTA: Dynamic Embedding Learning with Truncated Conscious Attention for CTR Predictioncited by 0
- 2023A Model-Agnostic Framework for Recommendation via Interest-aware Item Embeddingscited by 0
- 2024Cognitive Evolutionary Learning to Select Feature Interactions for Recommender Systemscited by 0
- 2024FINED: Feed Instance-Wise Information Need with Essential and Disentangled Parametric Knowledge from the Pastcited by 0
- 2025Large Foundation Model for Ads Recommendationcited by 0
- 2025Toward a benchmark for CTR prediction in online advertising: datasets, evaluation protocols and perspectivescited by 0
- 2026Distribution-Aware End-to-End Embedding for Streaming Numerical Features in Click-Through Rate Predictioncited by 0
- 2026Distribution-Aware End-to-End Embedding for Streaming Numerical Features in Click-Through Rate Prediction3 Feb 2026
- 2025Toward a benchmark for CTR prediction in online advertising: datasets, evaluation protocols and perspectives1 Dec 2025
- 2025Target-Aware Early Stage Ranking26 Nov 2025
- 2025Large Foundation Model for Ads Recommendation20 Aug 2025
- 2025Revisiting Feature Interactions from the Perspective of Quadratic Neural Networks for Click-through Rate Prediction23 May 2025
- 2024Cognitive Evolutionary Learning to Select Feature Interactions for Recommender Systems29 May 2024
- 2024FINED: Feed Instance-Wise Information Need with Essential and Disentangled Parametric Knowledge from the Past20 May 2024
- 2024DisCo: Towards Harmonious Disentanglement and Collaboration between Tabular and Semantic Space for Recommendation20 May 2024
- 2024Retrieval-Oriented Knowledge for Click-Through Rate Prediction28 Apr 2024
- 2024Retrieval and Distill: A Temporal Data Shift-Free Paradigm for Online Recommendation System24 Apr 2024
- 2023GFS: Graph-based Feature Synthesis for Prediction over Relational Databases4 Dec 2023
- 2023From Principle to Practice: Vertical Data Minimization for Machine Learning17 Nov 2023
32 more
- 2023Hiformer: Heterogeneous Feature Interactions Learning with Transformers for Recommender Systems10 Nov 2023
- 2023Towards Hybrid-grained Feature Interaction Selection for Deep Sparse Network23 Oct 2023
- 2023VFLAIR: A Research Library and Benchmark for Vertical Federated Learning15 Oct 2023
- 2023ClickPrompt: CTR Models are Strong Prompt Generators for Adapting Language Models to CTR Prediction13 Oct 2023
- 2023ROMO: Retrieval-enhanced Offline Model-based Optimization11 Oct 2023
- 2023A Model-Agnostic Framework for Recommendation via Interest-aware Item Embeddings17 Aug 2023
- 2023MAP: A Model-agnostic Pretraining Framework for Click-through Rate Prediction3 Aug 2023
- 2023Exploiting Field Dependencies for Learning on Categorical Data18 Jul 2023
- 2023DELTA: Dynamic Embedding Learning with Truncated Conscious Attention for CTR Prediction3 May 2023
- 2023AdaEnsemble: Learning Adaptively Sparse Structured Ensemble Network for Click-Through Rate Prediction6 Jan 2023
- 2023DynInt: Dynamic Interaction Modeling for Large-scale Click-Through Rate Prediction3 Jan 2023
- 2023xDeepInt: a hybrid architecture for modeling the vector-wise and bit-wise feature interactions3 Jan 2023
- 2022Directed Acyclic Graph Factorization Machines for CTR Prediction via Knowledge Distillation21 Nov 2022
- 2022Risk-Aware Bid Optimization for Online Display Advertisement28 Oct 2022
- 2022On-Device Model Fine-Tuning with Label Correction in Recommender Systems21 Oct 2022
- 2022Towards Understanding the Overfitting Phenomenon of Deep Click-Through Rate Prediction Models4 Sep 2022
- 2022Learning Enhanced Representations for Tabular Data via Neighborhood Propagation14 Jun 2022
- 2022A Comprehensive Survey on Automated Machine Learning for Recommendations4 Apr 2022
- 2022i-Razor: A Differentiable Neural Input Razor for Feature Selection and Dimension Search in DNN-Based Recommender Systems1 Apr 2022
- 2021MOEF: Modeling Occasion Evolution in Frequency Domain for Promotion-Aware Click-Through Rate Prediction27 Dec 2021
- 2021AEFE: Automatic Embedded Feature Engineering for Categorical Features19 Oct 2021
- 2021Secure Your Ride: Real-time Matching Success Rate Prediction for Passenger-Driver Pairs14 Sep 2021
- 2021TabGNN: Multiplex Graph Neural Network for Tabular Data Prediction20 Aug 2021
- 2021Task-wise Split Gradient Boosting Trees for Multi-center Diabetes Prediction16 Aug 2021
- 2021Memorize, Factorize, or be Na"ive: Learning Optimal Feature Interaction Methods for CTR Prediction3 Aug 2021
- 2021ARM-Net: Adaptive Relation Modeling Network for Structured Data5 Jul 2021
- 2021Online Interaction Detection for Click-Through Rate Prediction27 Jun 2021
- 2021Muddling Label Regularization: Deep Learning for Tabular Datasets8 Jun 2021
- 2021XCrossNet: Feature Structure-Oriented Learning for Click-Through Rate Prediction22 Apr 2021
- 2021Deep Learning for Click-Through Rate Estimation21 Apr 2021
- 2021ScaleFreeCTR: MixCache-based Distributed Training System for CTR Models with Huge Embedding Table17 Apr 2021
- 2021User Response Prediction in Online Advertising7 Jan 2021
- 2021Deep Learning for Click-Through Rate Estimationcited by 33
- 2022Towards Understanding the Overfitting Phenomenon of Deep Click-Through Rate Prediction Modelscited by 33
- 2023ClickPrompt: CTR Models are Strong Prompt Generators for Adapting Language Models to CTR Predictioncited by 27
- 2021TabGNN: Multiplex Graph Neural Network for Tabular Data Predictioncited by 26
- 2021ARM-Net: Adaptive Relation Modeling Network for Structured Datacited by 24
- 2023GFS: Graph-based Feature Synthesis for Prediction over Relational Databasescited by 16
- 2021User Response Prediction in Online Advertisingcited by 15
- 2023Hiformer: Heterogeneous Feature Interactions Learning with Transformers for Recommender Systemscited by 14
- 2021ScaleFreeCTR: MixCache-based Distributed Training System for CTR Models with Huge Embedding Tablecited by 12
- 2021Memorize, Factorize, or be Na"ive: Learning Optimal Feature Interaction Methods for CTR Predictioncited by 12
- 2023MAP: A Model-agnostic Pretraining Framework for Click-through Rate Predictioncited by 10
- 2023VFLAIR: A Research Library and Benchmark for Vertical Federated Learningcited by 8
12 most cited of 43 All 43 (JSON)
- 2026Distribution-Aware End-to-End Embedding for Streaming Numerical Features in Click-Through Rate Prediction3 Feb 2026
- 2025Toward a benchmark for CTR prediction in online advertising: datasets, evaluation protocols and perspectives1 Dec 2025
- 2025Target-Aware Early Stage Ranking26 Nov 2025
- 2025Large Foundation Model for Ads Recommendation20 Aug 2025
- 2025Revisiting Feature Interactions from the Perspective of Quadratic Neural Networks for Click-through Rate Prediction23 May 2025
- 2024Cognitive Evolutionary Learning to Select Feature Interactions for Recommender Systems29 May 2024
- 2024FINED: Feed Instance-Wise Information Need with Essential and Disentangled Parametric Knowledge from the Past20 May 2024
- 2024DisCo: Towards Harmonious Disentanglement and Collaboration between Tabular and Semantic Space for Recommendation20 May 2024
- 2024Retrieval-Oriented Knowledge for Click-Through Rate Prediction28 Apr 2024
- 2024Retrieval and Distill: A Temporal Data Shift-Free Paradigm for Online Recommendation System24 Apr 2024
- 2023GFS: Graph-based Feature Synthesis for Prediction over Relational Databases4 Dec 2023
- 2023From Principle to Practice: Vertical Data Minimization for Machine Learning17 Nov 2023
12 newest of 43 All 43 (JSON)