VIGIL: Tackling Hallucination Detection in Image Recontextualization

We introduce VIGIL (Visual Inconsistency & Generative In-context Lucidity), a benchmark dataset and framework that provides a fine-grained categorization of hallucinations in the multimodal image recontextualization task for large multimodal models. Most existing methods treat hallucinations as a single undifferentiated error. We instead decompose them into five categories, namely Object Visual Fidelity, Background Fidelity, Spatial and Instructional Fidelity, Physical and Integration Fidelity, and Object Omission. We propose a multi-stage detection pipeline that processes recontextualized images through specialized steps targeting all five categories with a coordinated set of open-source models. We evaluate the pipeline on the VIGIL dataset of 1,269 manually annotated samples across five product domains and report macro-F1 per category. The decomposed pipeline reaches the best macro-F1 among open-source detectors. It returns a textual explanation for each detected error, which prior methods for this task do not provide. We openly release VIGIL, along with the detection pipeline and benchmark code, through our GitHub repository: https://github.com/mlubneuskaya/vigil and Data repository: https://huggingface.co/datasets/joannaww/VIGIL.