Supervising Ralph Wiggum: Exploring a Metacognitive Co-Regulation Agentic AI Loop for Engineering Design

The engineering design research community has studied agentic AI systems that use Large Language Model (LLM) agents to automate the engineering design process. However, these systems are prone to some of the same pathologies that plague humans. Just as human designers, LLM design agents can fixate on existing paradigms and fail to explore alternatives when solving design challenges, potentially leading to suboptimal solutions. In this work, we propose (1) a novel Self-Regulation Loop (SRL), in which the Design Agent self-regulates and explicitly monitors its own metacognition, and (2) a novel Co-Regulation Design Agentic Loop (CRDAL), in which a Metacognitive Co-Regulation Agent assists the Design Agent in metacognition to mitigate design fixation, thereby improving system performance for engineering design tasks. In the battery pack design problem examined here, we found that the novel SRL and CRDAL systems generate designs with better performance, without significantly increasing the computational cost, compared to a plain Ralph Wiggum Loop (RWL) Further, the novel CRDAL generates designs with significantly better performance than SRL. Also, we found that the CRDAL system navigated through the latent design space more effectively than both SRL and RWL. The proposed system architectures and findings of this work provide practical implications for future development of agentic AI systems for engineering design.