Efficient Ensemble for Fine-tuning Language Models on Multiple Datasets

This paper develops an ensemble method for fine-tuning a language model to multiple datasets. Existing methods, such as quantized LoRA (QLoRA), are efficient when adapting to a single dataset. When training on multiple datasets of different tasks, a common setup in practice, it remains unclear how to design an efficient adaptation for fine-tuning language models. We propose to use an ensemble of multiple smaller adapters instead of a single adapter per task. We design an efficient algorithm that partitions n datasets into m groups, where m is typically much smaller than n in practice, and train one adapter for each group before taking a weighted combination to form the ensemble. The algorithm leverages a first-order approximation property of low-rank adaptation to quickly obtain the fine-tuning performances of dataset combinations since methods like LoRA stay close to the base model. Hence, we use the gradients of the base model to estimate its behavior during fine-tuning. Empirically, this approximation holds with less than 1% error on models with up to 34 billion parameters, leading to an estimation of true fine-tuning performances under 5% error while speeding up computation compared to base fine-tuning by 105 times. When applied to fine-tune Llama and GPT models on ten text classification tasks, our approach provides up to 10% higher average test accuracy over QLoRA, with only 9% more FLOPs. On a Llama model with 34 billion parameters, an ensemble of QLoRA increases test accuracy by 3% compared to QLoRA, with only 8% more FLOPs.