Supervised perceptron learning vs unsupervised Hebbian unlearning: Approaching optimal memory retrieval in Hopfield-like networks

The Hebbian unlearning algorithm, i.e. an unsupervised local procedure used to improve the retrieval properties in Hopfield-like neural networks, is numerically compared to a supervised algorithm to train a linear symmetric perceptron. We analyze the stability of the stored memories: basins of attraction obtained by the Hebbian unlearning technique are found to be comparable in size to those obtained in the symmetric perceptron, while the two algorithms are found to converge in the same region of Gardner's space of interactions, having followed similar learning paths. A geometric interpretation of Hebbian unlearning is proposed to explain its optimal performances. Because the Hopfield model is also a prototypical model of disordered magnetic system, it might be possible to translate our results to other models of interest for memory storage in materials.