Fast Best Subset Selection: Coordinate Descent and Local Combinatorial Optimization Algorithms

The L0-regularized least squares problem (a.k.a. best subsets) is central to sparse statistical learning and has attracted significant attention across the wider statistics, machine learning, and optimization communities. Recent work has shown that modern mixed integer optimization (MIO) solvers can be used to address small to moderate instances of this problem. In spite of the usefulness of L0-based estimators and generic MIO solvers, there is a steep computational price to pay when compared to popular sparse learning algorithms (e.g., based on L1 regularization). In this paper, we aim to push the frontiers of computation for a family of L0-regularized problems with additional convex penalties. We propose a new hierarchy of necessary optimality conditions for these problems. We develop fast algorithms, based on coordinate descent and local combinatorial optimization, that are guaranteed to converge to solutions satisfying these optimality conditions. From a statistical viewpoint, an interesting story emerges. When the signal strength is high, our combinatorial optimization algorithms have an edge in challenging statistical settings. When the signal is lower, pure L0 benefits from additional convex regularization. We empirically demonstrate that our family of L0-based estimators can outperform the state-of-the-art sparse learning algorithms in terms of a combination of prediction, estimation, and variable selection metrics under various regimes (e.g., different signal strengths, feature correlations, number of samples and features). Our new open-source sparse learning toolkit L0Learn (available on CRAN and Github) reaches up to a three-fold speedup (with p up to 106) when compared to competing toolkits such as glmnet and ncvreg.