Transcribing Children's Speech: ASR Performance and Obtaining Reliable Orthographic Transcriptions

Automatic speech recognition (ASR) has the potential to substantially reduce manual annotation effort in child speech research by generating automatic transcriptions. However, obtaining reliably high-quality ASR transcriptions for child speech remains challenging in low-resource languages due to limited child-specific pre-trained models and highly diverse noise conditions. This study investigates the effectiveness of state-of-the-art ASR models on child speech through two research questions, by evaluating nine ASR models from three model families (Whisper, Parakeet, and Wav2Vec2) on two Dutch child speech datasets, JASMIN and DART. Research question 1 examines the performance of ASR-models applied to child speech. The fine-tuned Whisper-medium model achieves the best overall performance, with a WER of 5.54% on JASMIN and 70.37% on DART, showing that the noisy DART data are clearly more challenging. Research question 2 examines to what extent it is possible to select a subset for which reliable orthographic transcriptions can be obtained automatically, without the need for manual verification. We use an utterance-level selection method that compares ASR output with the original read prompt to identify correctly pronounced recordings. Using the proposed selection method, 42.0% [for JASMIN] and 18.1% [for DART] of the utterances can be automatically identified as correctly pronounced with high confidence, resulting in very low error rates on an utterance level (precisions of 98.3% and higher) and reducing the need for manual verification.