Teaching Language Models Mechanistic Explainability Through MechSMILES

Chemical reaction mechanisms are the foundation of how chemists evaluate reactivity and feasibility, yet current Computer-Assisted Synthesis Planning (CASP) systems operate without this mechanistic reasoning. We introduce a computational framework that teaches language models to predict reaction mechanisms through arrow-pushing formalism, a century-old notation that tracks electron flow while enforcing conservation of mass and charge. This mechanistic understanding enables three capabilities that are difficult or impossible with current methods: post-hoc validation of CASP proposals by reconstructing physically plausible electron pathways, holistic atom-to-atom mapping that tracks all atoms including hydrogens, and extraction of catalyst-aware reaction templates that distinguish recycled catalysts from spectator species. Central to our approach is MechSMILES, a compact textual format encoding molecular structure and electron flow through three arrow types, designed within a Python-based environment that enforces conservation laws and eliminates the possibility of atom hallucination. We trained and benchmarked models on four mechanism prediction tasks of increasing complexity using the main mechanistic datasets in the literature. On our most challenging task, predicting complete mechanisms given only reactants, conditions, and the desired product, our models achieve 93.2% and 73.3% pathway retrieval on the FlowER and mech-USPTO-31k datasets respectively, with top-3 retrieval reaching 97.6% and 86.5%. Furthermore, the framework rapidly learns new reaction classes, with strong mechanistic predictions for ozonolysis and Suzuki cross-coupling emerging from as few as 40 training examples each. By grounding predictions in physically meaningful electron movements, this work provides an architecture-agnostic, open-source foundation for more explainable and chemically valid CASP.