On the power of linear programming for K-means clustering

In [SIAM J. Optim., 2022], the authors introduced a new linear programming (LP) relaxation for K-means clustering. In this paper, we further investigate both theoretical and computational properties of this relaxation. As evident from our numerical experiments with both synthetic real-world data sets, the proposed LP relaxation is almost always tight; i.e. its optimal solution is feasible for the original nonconvex problem. To better understand this unexpected behaviour, on the theoretical side, we focus on K-means clustering with two clusters, and we obtain sufficient conditions under which the LP relaxation is tight. We further analyze the sufficient conditions when the input is generated according to a popular stochastic model and obtain recovery guarantees for the LP relaxation. We conclude our theoretical study by constructing a family of inputs for which the LP relaxation is never tight. Denoting by n the number of data points to be clustered, the LP relaxation contains Omega(n3) inequalities making it impractical for large data sets. To address the scalability issue, by building upon a cutting-plane algorithm together with the GPU implementation of PDLP, a first-order method LP solver, we develop an efficient algorithm that solves the proposed LP and hence the K-means clustering problem, for up to n ≤ 4000 data points.