The Conditioning Bias in Binary Decision Trees and Random Forests and Its Elimination

Decision tree and random forest classification and regression are some of the most widely used in machine learning approaches. Binary decision tree implementations commonly use conditioning in the form 'feature ≤ (or <) threshold', with the threshold being the midpoint between two observed feature values. In this paper, we investigate the bias introduced by the choice of conditioning operator (an intrinsic property of implementations) in the presence of features with lattice characteristics. We propose techniques to eliminate this bias, requiring an additional prediction with decision trees and incurring no cost for random forests. Using 20 classification and 20 regression datasets, we demonstrate that the bias can lead to statistically significant differences in terms of AUC and r2 scores. The proposed techniques successfully mitigate the bias, compared to the worst-case scenario, statistically significant improvements of up to 0.1-0.2 percentage points of AUC and r2 scores were achieved and the improvement of 1.5 percentage points of r2 score was measured in the most sensitive case of random forest regression. The implementation of the study is available on GitHub at the following repository: urlhttps://github.com/gykovacs/conditioningbias.