On the exact feasibility of convex scenario programs with discarded constraints

We revisit the so-called sampling and discarding approach used to quantify the probability of constraint violation of a solution to convex scenario programs when some of the original samples are allowed to be discarded. Motivated by two scenario programs that possess analytic solutions and the fact that the existing bound for scenario programs with discarded constraints is not tight, we analyze a removal scheme that consists of a cascade of optimization problems, where at each step we remove a superset of the active constraints. By relying on results from compression learning theory, we show that such a removal scheme leads to less conservative bounds for the probability of constraint violation than the existing ones. We also show that the proposed bound is tight by characterizing a class of optimization problems that achieves the given upper bound. The performance improvement of the proposed methodology is illustrated by an example that involves a resource sharing linear program.